Search
  • Stephen Biss

Prima Facie Reliability 2


Some lawyers think that the Alcohol Test Committee 2012 Position Paper states that the defence does not need to obtain any documentation of the evidentiary breath test process other than that produced by the instrument during the subject tests.

In Ontario, scientists from the Centre of Forensic Science are likely to concede, that the results of the three QA (quality assurance) tests, at start of shift are part of the documentation that any expert needs to see in forming an opinion as to the reliability of the tests. These three tests: stand-alone diagnostics, stand-alone calibration check, and stand-alone self breath test are performed in Ontario at start of shift or immediately prior to the subject breath tests by qualified technicians who are following the requirements of the CFS 8000C Training Aid. They should form part of normal Stinchcombe disclosure in Ontario because they are associated with the subject tests of the accused. Both "passed" and "failed" tests should be disclosed. (1)

To the best of my knowledge, these 3 quality assurance tests are not required in other provinces. Please write to me at biss@lawyers.ca if I am incorrect.

On the 8000C with Ontario hardware and software, a stand-alone diagnostics test begins with the keyboard sequence Esc Esc D. Please see page 7-5 or page 82 of 238 in the CFS 8000C Training Aid.

On the 8000C with Ontario hardware and software, a stand-alone calibration check begins with the keyboard sequence Esc Esc C. Please see pages 7-15 to 7-17 and 8-14 or p. 143 of 238 in the CFS 8000C Training Aid.

On the 8000C, with Ontario hardware and software, a stand-alone self breath test is commenced with the keyboard sequence Esc Esc B. Please see page 8-14 or p. 143 of 238 of the CFS 8000C Training Aid.

Warning: These images and videos may not be used in Court. They are not evidence. The author is not an expert witness. These images and videos are for discussion among lawyers.

(1) "Just as it is not for the Crown to withhold a witness statement that contains potentially relevant evidence because, in its assessment, the witness is incredible or unreliable, it is not for the Crown to decide which quality assurance test results that are associated with an accused’s breath tests are worthy of disclosure." R. v. O., 2014 ONCJ 440 at para. 127.

#escescb #reliability #diagnosticsok

25 views

© 2020 Allbiss Lawdata Ltd. All rights reserved. This is not a government web site.

 

 

For more information respecting this database or to report misuse contact: Allbiss Lawdata Ltd., 303-470 Hensall Circle, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada, L5A 3V4, 905-273-3322. The author and the participants make no representation or warranty  whatsoever as to the authenticity and reliability of the information contained herein.  WARNING: All information contained herein is provided  for the purpose of discussion and peer review only and should not be construed as formal legal advice. The authors disclaim any and all liability resulting from reliance upon such information. You are strongly encouraged to seek professional legal advice before relying upon any of the information contained herein. Legal advice should be sought directly from a properly retained lawyer or attorney. 

WARNING: Please do not attempt to use any text, image, or video that you see on this site in Court. These comments, images, and videos are NOT EVIDENCE. The Courts will need to hear evidence from a properly qualified expert. The author is not a scientist. The author is not an expert. These pages exist to promote discussion among defence lawyers.

 

Intoxilyzer®  is a registered trademark of CMI, Inc. The Intoxilyzer® 5000C is an "approved instrument" in Canada.
Breathalyzer® is a registered trademark of Draeger Safety, Inc., Breathalyzer Division. The owner of the trademark is Robert F. Borkenstein and Draeger Safety, Inc. has leased the exclusive rights of use from him. The Breathalyzer® 900 and Breathalyzer® 900A were "approved instruments" in Canada.
DrugTest® 5000 is also a registered trademark of Draeger Safety, Inc.. DrugTest® 5000 is "approved drug screening equipment" in Canada.
Alcotest® is a registered trademark of Draeger Safety, Inc. The Alcotest® 7410 GLC and 6810 are each an "approved screening device" in Canada.
Datamaster®  is a registered trademark of National Patent Analytical Systems, Inc.  The BAC Datamaster® C  is an "approved instrument" in Canada.