Search
  • Stephen Biss

What is a lawyer-scientist? Video 0006


Start by moving the slider and watching the end of this video at 2:25. This old Intoxilyzer® 5000 has just printed an Intoxilyzer® Test Record of a Stand-alone Diagnostic.

Perhaps the difference between a DUI lawyer and a DUI lawyer-scientist is that the lawyer-scientist strives to understand and investigate the science behind the forensic evidence of measurement of blood alcohol concentration.

I am not an expert. I am an advocate. I am not a scientist, but I am a lawyer who asks scientific questions of the police and of government experts when I believe scientific method is being violated. Perhaps I aspire to be a DUI lawyer-scientist. I hope an exploration of scientific method makes me a better advocate.

Go back to the beginning of this video. Any breath measurement by police is a scientific measurement using a measurement instrument that has some degree of uncertainty. .

As Justin McShane, a colleague in Pennsylvania, has said, "Science and law must win out in the courtroom not hysteria." Scientific method must be at the root of drunk driving charges, defence, trials, acquittals, and convictions. I strongly recommend Justin McShane's blog on the Justin Bieber DUI charges. In his thorough blog article he explores the law and science of DUI charges.

#diagnosticsok #5000

3 views

© 2020 Allbiss Lawdata Ltd. All rights reserved. This is not a government web site.

 

 

For more information respecting this database or to report misuse contact: Allbiss Lawdata Ltd., 303-470 Hensall Circle, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada, L5A 3V4, 905-273-3322. The author and the participants make no representation or warranty  whatsoever as to the authenticity and reliability of the information contained herein.  WARNING: All information contained herein is provided  for the purpose of discussion and peer review only and should not be construed as formal legal advice. The authors disclaim any and all liability resulting from reliance upon such information. You are strongly encouraged to seek professional legal advice before relying upon any of the information contained herein. Legal advice should be sought directly from a properly retained lawyer or attorney. 

WARNING: Please do not attempt to use any text, image, or video that you see on this site in Court. These comments, images, and videos are NOT EVIDENCE. The Courts will need to hear evidence from a properly qualified expert. The author is not a scientist. The author is not an expert. These pages exist to promote discussion among defence lawyers.

 

Intoxilyzer®  is a registered trademark of CMI, Inc. The Intoxilyzer® 5000C is an "approved instrument" in Canada.
Breathalyzer® is a registered trademark of Draeger Safety, Inc., Breathalyzer Division. The owner of the trademark is Robert F. Borkenstein and Draeger Safety, Inc. has leased the exclusive rights of use from him. The Breathalyzer® 900 and Breathalyzer® 900A were "approved instruments" in Canada.
DrugTest® 5000 is also a registered trademark of Draeger Safety, Inc.. DrugTest® 5000 is "approved drug screening equipment" in Canada.
Alcotest® is a registered trademark of Draeger Safety, Inc. The Alcotest® 7410 GLC and 6810 are each an "approved screening device" in Canada.
Datamaster®  is a registered trademark of National Patent Analytical Systems, Inc.  The BAC Datamaster® C  is an "approved instrument" in Canada.